| Rank | Aggregate | Match | Season | Event |
| 1 |
749 |
Dominic Mulhall (585) vs Michael Williams (164) |
2008/09 |
ABC: Cambridge |
| 2 |
734 |
Billy Bousfield (425) vs Martin Gawthrop (309) |
2003/04 |
ABC: Stoke |
| 3 |
707 |
Mark Hatton (583) vs Brian Moffatt (124) |
2002/03 |
ABC: Nuneaton |
| 4 |
705 |
Phil Mumford (552) vs Mark Graham (153) |
2006/07 |
ABC: Leeds |
| 5 |
701 |
Phillip Welham (584) vs Eva Palmius (117) |
2005/06 |
ABC: Cambridge |
| 6 |
697 |
Martin Goodwill (535) vs Martin Phillips (162) |
2007/08 |
ABC: Birmingham |
| 7 |
696 |
Mark Hatton (453) vs Robert Hall (243) |
2002/03 |
ABC: Newmarket |
| 8 |
694 |
Brian Harvey (382) vs Jim McCann (312) |
2006/07 |
ABC: Leeds |
| 9 |
693 |
Dominic Mulhall (460) vs Chris Mitchell (233) |
2009/10 |
ABC: Leeds |
| 10 |
689 |
Dominic Mulhall (548) vs Phil Davis (141) |
2008/09 |
ABC: Birmingham |
| 11 |
672 |
Martin Goodwill (618) vs Jerry Conba (54) |
2007/08 |
ABC: Cambridge |
| 12 |
670 |
Peter Shelley (422) vs Branson Hoole (248) |
2003/04 |
ABC: Stoke |
| 13 |
666 |
Stephen Crosland (373) vs Bill Andress (293) |
2002/03 |
ABC: Queensferry |
| 14 |
665 |
Martin Goodwill (615) vs Geoff Anderson (50) |
2005/06 |
ABC: Cambridge |
| 15 |
663 |
Anthony Bishop (455) vs Kyle Cunningham (208) |
2003/04 |
ABC: Nuneaton |
| 16 |
660 |
Peter Shelley (496) vs Rodney Simms (164) |
2003/04 |
ABC: Bradford |
| 17 |
659 |
Phil Mumford (543) vs John Smith (116) |
2009/10 |
ABC: Birmingham |
| 18 |
657 |
Branson Hoole (369) vs David Rees (288) |
2005/06 |
ABC: Haverhill |
| 19 |
657 |
Phil Mumford (432) vs Steve Hardcastle (225) |
2008/09 |
ABC: Leeds |
| 20 |
656 |
Phillip Welham (377) vs Brian Harvey (279) |
2002/03 |
ABC: Queensferry |