EABAonline
The Billiards Quarterly Review : October 1993

A.B.C. 1993 -1994

Amateur Billiards Circuit: First Event September 12th

Leeds Star Snooker

Pro-Am: Professionals invited to play

The Amateur Billiards Circuit returned to the Star Snooker for the Fred Cundall Trophy which, in the event, was not presented as the promised sponsorship was withdrawn. As the organisers were also informed - very late in the day - that the table time would have to be paid for - the prize money was rather lower than usual. This was something of a let down and was more keenly felt than it might have been by virtue of the fact that the event had been made completely open attracting a number of professional players including the world No. 4 Peter Gilchrist, No.7 Bob Close, and No. 10 John Murphy. The Star Snooker Club is a good venue and very handy for players from the North and Midlands. Whether Derek Townend will feel he will want go there again next year is open to some doubt.

Handicaps

The tournament was handicapped on the following basis for the hour-long main competition games. All ranked professional players conceded 100 start. Professionals not in the current ranking list and two top amateur players, i.e. David Causier and Martin Goodwill conceded 50 start. All other players were on the scratch mark with the exception of a few players who were conceded an extra 50 points. These players were those who, on the basis of last season's ABC, averaged less than 200 per hour in all their games. This resulted in some unfairness and particularly in the case of the BQR Editor who, by virtue of having played in every tournament and having had a couple of dreadful games last year had managed an average of 199 and so, notwithstanding a quite respectable position in the ABC ranking list, was rather embarrassingly given the extra 50. His first round opponent turned out to be Ron Whitten of Peterlee who was playing in his first ABC event after not having played any serious billiards for over four years. As Mr. Whitton had no ABC record he was placed on the scratch mark and so conceded the BQR Editor 50 points. Mr. Whitton sportingly accepted the handicap. The BQR editor could, of course, have refused the start, but this would have seemed very condescending and would have undermined Derek Townend's system. It would also have been rather discourteous as anyone entering a competition should abide by the rules thereof even if this seems to give them an unfair advantage. Ted Warren of Leeds was another player to cause a few raised eyebrows at being given the start. To be fair to the organiser a handicapping system has to start somewhere, but handicapping on the basis of a player's hourly average is perhaps not the best of ideas. Tom Terry should, incidentally, have made a little more effort whilst he had the chance, he has been informed that it ain't going to happen again!

Prizes for Goodwill and Bennett

Before the draw was made two prizes were awarded for the biggest breaks made during last season's ABC series. Martin Goodwill was presented with the Jock McGregor prize for his effort of 309 made in the very last event at Stoke and which just beat David Causier's 300 made at Exeter. Paul Bennett received the Ivan Stevenage (Ivan IV) prize for the highest break by a junior player - 89. It will require a very good effort indeed if any amateur is to beat Goodwill's record but it is a safe bet that it will take a break of at least a century to take the junior prize this year.

First Round

Goodwill and Close beaten Centuries for McCann and Shutt The first round saw some notable fallers. Walter Reed of Doncaster knocked up a 60 odd at almost his first visit against Bob Close giving him a lead of 160 which the Hartlepool professional could not overcome. Other professionals to fall at the first were Howard Griffiths, David Rees, and Dave Seddon. The biggest upset was perhaps the defeat of Martin Goodwill by the young Nottingham player Jamie Moore. Moore was in receipt of 50 but beat the twice Amateur Champion by more than the start. Both Jim McCann and Under 16 champion Chris Shutt had fine century breaks.

P. Bennett
64
347  G. Tutt (+50)
188 
T. McFarlane
374  K. Hobbs
113 
P. Welham
278  S. Crosland
246 
W. Reed
60
288  R. Close (-100)
73
228 
E. Warren (+50)
85
389  T. Hodby
199 
B. Harvey
67, 65
317  J. Bayes (+50)
221 
Whiteley
53, 57
361  J. Barker (+50)
184 
B. Hoole
364  D. Seddon (-50)
243 
J. Moore
301  M. Goodwill (-50)
226 
J. Murphy
220  I. Stevenage (+50)
190 
M. Hirst
214  R. Lodge
202 
J. McCann
127
397  H. Griffiths (-50)
151 
J. Murphy (-100)
81
474  P. Ostrowski (+50)
253 
R. Sutcliffe
54
293  B. Dix (+50)
187 
J. Carman (+50)
240  R. Wilson (+50)
234 
D. Kell
273  R. Watts
181 
R. Simms
52
287  B. Moore (+50)
224 
G. Evans (+50)
368  C. Brunskill (+50)
240 
T. Terry (+50)
60, 50
403  R. Whitton
151 
G. Cromack
290  B. French
186 
G. Willis (+50)
241  B. Veriato
174 
L. Cuthbert
68, 58, 51
322  A. Mackinder
195 
C. Shutt
149, 99
474  D. Rees (-50)
217 
A. Orton
289  S. Best
163 
R. Chapman (-50)
288  M. Raine
277 
Second Round
Record break from Gilchrist; Two centuries for Chapman

Peter Gilchrist made light of conceding 150 to Jock McGregor and played out time with a beautiful top-of-the-table break of 390 unfinished. This is a record for the ABC but may not qualify for the McGregor prize as that is for the best break by an amateur. Peterborough professional Roxton Chapman weighed in with two fine centuries (177.133) against Alan Orton, but John Murphy was unable to give Bill Andress a hundred. Amateur Champion David Causier had a century and was looking on good form.

T. McFarlane
235  P. Bennett
56
212 
W. Reed
232  P. Welham
173 
B. Harvey
55
240  E. Warren (+50)
232 
B. Hoole
257  S. Whiteley
222 
Jim Murphy
269  J. Moore
206 
M. Hirst
70
237  J. McCann
159 
W. Andress
68
405  J. Murphy (-100)
68
351 
P. Gilchrist (-100)
75, 390unf
706  J. McGregor
188 
D. Causier (-50)
135
467  M. Graham
61
233 
D. White
233  R. Moore (+50)
207 
J. Carman (+50)
264  R. Sutcliffe
160 
D. Kell
305  R. Simms
167 
T. Terry (+50)
50, 66
252  G. Evans (+50)
196 
G. Cromack
219  G. Willis (+50)
199 
L. Cuthbert
287  C. Shutt
227 
R. Chapman (-50)
177, 133
436  A. Orton
136 
Third Round
More centuries from Gilchrist and Causier

Both Gilchrist and Causier made big breaks and came through with little difficulty. With these two in different halves it was beginning to look odds on for them to meet in the final. Walter Reed did well to get past Tom McFarlane though by only 17. Brian Harvey has beaten Branson Hoole the last half-dozen times they have met and remarked before the game that he thought it might be Branson's turn this time; it was - by just 12 points -Harvey being in play with 75 at the bell. With Chapman losing to Lee Cuthbert by just 10, Gilchrist was the only professional left in the field.

W. Reed
53
202  T. McFarlane
54
185 
B. Hoole
80
300  B. Harvey
77, 75unf
288 
M. Hirst
348  Jim Murphy
110 
P. Gilchrist (-100)
95, 160
461  W. Andress
319 
D. Causier (-50)
127
451  D. White
207 
D. Kell
277  J. Carman (+50)
139 
G. Cromack
62
325  T. Terry (+50)
276 
L. Cuthbert
266  R. Chapman (-50)
255 
Quarter-Finals
Cromack wins the Battle of Thornaby

Glen Cromack and Lee Cuthbert, both of Thornaby, and both products of the Teesside Boys, met at this stage, Cromack's fine break of 114 making the difference. Gilchrist and Causier again swept away the opposition with century breaks. Walter Reed, in his first ABC progressed to the semi with an excellent win over Branson Hoole.

W. Reed
236  B. Hoole
201 
P. Gilchrist (-100)
54, 97, 116
460  M. Hirst
269 
D. Causier (-50)
63, 66, 167
626  D. Kell
225 
G. Cromack
114
358  L. Cuthbert
190 
Semi-Finals
Reed's Run Ends

Walter Reed did well against Gilchrist for half-an-hour or so as a few 20 breaks added to his 100 start gave him a good lead. But the genial Middlesbrough man came in strongly towards the end, runs of 120 and 112 taking him comfortably to the Final. Causier struggled against Cuthbert, but he too came in strongly towards the end of the game to win by just over 100.

P. Gilchrist (-100)
120, 112
372  W. Reed
273 
D. Causier (-50)
399  G. Cromack
275 
Final
Exciting Finish

The game, for the most part, was something of an anti-climax considering how well the two players had performed during the earlier rounds. In a somewhat scrappy affair, Causier took advantage of his 50 start, and with an 87, built up a lead of over 100. Gilchrist gradually whittled this down and with the clock showing two minutes to go was 25 behind. 29 unfinished saw the professional the winner by the narrow margin of 4 points. An exciting finish to a good day's play.

P. Gilchrist (-100)
98
340  D. Causier (-50)
87
336 

Leeds Plate

Goodwill completes miserable day
First Round

Martin Goodwill completed the double of a first round dismissal in both competitions. He was in good company as World No.7 Bob Close suffered a similar fate. It happens to the best at times. It could be a long time before it happens again. The closest game was that in which Mark Graham beat Derby veteran Ken Hobbs by just 1. Handicaps were halved for the half-hour plate games.

M. Graham
112  K. Hobbs
111 
A. Mackinder
188  H. Griffiths (-50)
65 
G. Tutt
157  C. Brunskill
90 
R. Watts
169  P. Ostrowski (+50)
78 
R. Whitten
w/o  B. Dix
scr 
R. Lodge
176  J. Barker (+50)
114 
Best
201  R. Close (-100)
118 
T. Hodby
w/o  D. Rees (-50)
  
R. Moore
n/r  R. Wilson
n/r 
Crosland
170  M. Goodwill (-50)
96 
B. French
115  I. Stevenage (+50)
72 
M. Raine
128  J. McGregor (+50)
110 
Second Round
A. Mackinder
125  M. Graham
86 
R. Watts
140  G. Tutt
122 
R. Whitton
127  R. Lodge
103 
D. Seddon (-50)
219  B. Moore (+50)
90 
B. Veriato
w/o  v J. Bayes (+50)
  
Best
145  T. Hodby
115 
Crosland
52
226  R. Moore (+50)
50 
M. Raine
145  B. French
132 
Quarter Finals
Very good win for Whitten

Ron Whitten would have been well pleased with his fine win over Scottish professional Dave Seddon in which he had a 73 break. Crosland scored like a house on fire against Mick Raine.

A. Mackinder
175  R. Watts
102 
R. Whitton
73
180  D. Seddon (-50)
127 
B. Veriato
165  S. Best
85 
Crosland
85, 63, 52
272  M. Raine
31 
Semi-Finals
Well done Benny

Steve Crosland's plate form had marked him out as a likely winner but he was well beaten by Benny Veriato. Ron Whitten went down to fellow Teessider Tony Mackinder.

A. Mackinder
161  R. Whitton
88 
B. Veriato
146  S. Crosland
96 
Plate Final
Mackinder well on top with a century

For the first time the Plate Final was played over an hour. This is a good idea as it gives the finalists a longer game, can be played concurrently with the main final, and cuts out any possible distraction if finishing half-way through the main. Benny Veriato could not get going at all and was largely a spectator as Mackinder ran up a series of breaks including a 101.

A. Mackinder
101, 80, 51
354  B. Veriato
96 
A very good day's billiards in a good venue. Whether the ABC will visit the Star next year will remain in doubt. The introduction of professional players was an unqualified success. The play of Peter Gilchrist in particular was a great attraction and there were considerably more spectators at the semis and final than usual. The ABC is a wonderful thing for the game and if it becomes a fairly regular Pro-Am then enthusiasts in many parts of the country will get the opportunity to see the stars in action. Handicapping makes the better players play hard from the word go, it encourages the not quite so good men, and is likely to be here to stay. The method of handicapping needs some revision but doubtless Derek Townend will have it right for the next event.

Amateur Billiards Circuit: Second Event, October 10th

Northampton Derngate Snooker Centre

The ABC returned to Derngate where, a year ago to the very day, there were 51 entrants including Martin Goodwill who was the eventual winner. David Causier was absent last year but was among the 40 entrants this year. Compared with last year's entry, and with the 50 strong amateur entry at Leeds, this was a rather disappointing turnout. It is still too early in the season to draw any conclusions but the figure of 40 is 9 less than the average turnout last year. It will be interesting to see what the entry figure will be at Widnes (November 14th) when the tournament will be Pro-Am.

Derngate is a good venue from the point of view of accessibility. Playing conditions vary, and though there are less tables available than last year, the tournament went very smoothly. Derek Townend might have had some difficulty had there been a larger entry.

First Round
Good Win for Wally Reed

Doncaster player Wally Reed had a very good tournament at Leeds, and carried on where he left off with a good win over the veteran Dick Watts. Reed is himself not a youngster. He is a good stroke-player and potter who is not afraid to give the balls a fair old trip round the table from time to time. When a player of this type gets the balls running he can be a difficult proposition over just one hour - as Bob Close remarked after losing to him at Leeds.

T. Terry
68
245  J. Conba
232 
W. Reed
289  R. Watts
279 
J. McCann
504  C. Hudson
69 
R. Sutcliffe
290  J. Scott
183 
Whiteley
306  M. Billinge
154 
D. Causier
62
392  W. Andress
285 
B. French
55
300  T. Hodby
198 
G. Evans
305  A. Parson
223 
Second Round
Ross shut out

The experienced Chris Ross found himself on the end of a string of breaks from the relatively inexperienced Under 16 champion Chris Shutt. Wally Reed gave Tom Terry little chance. David Causier began to get into his stride with a couple of nineties.

W. Reed
218  T. Terry
135 
J. McCann
53
238  R. Sutcliffe
194 
J. Hedley
58
443  F. Page
103 
P. Bennett
242  M. White
194 
B. Hoole
86
304  A. Marsden
50
197 
Crosland
89
315  T. Smith
166 
K. Hobbs
70
335  H. Willis
132 
G. Willis
235  J. McGregor
128 
M. Hirst
189  B. Dix
162 
C. Shutt
86, 83
544  C. Ross
151 
R. Warren
51
288  J. Barker
158 
J. Moore
62, 54
330  R. Shanks
108 
P. Welham
52
233  G. Tutt
205 
Whiteley
303  R. Moore
186 
D. Causier
93, 93, 64
508  B. French
160 
G. Evans
252  I. Stevenage
143 
Third Round
Century from Reed

Wally Reed had a very good win indeed over Jim McCann making his personal record break of 118 in the process. Shutt had another good win in beating Mark Hirst

W. Reed
118
256  J. McCann
63
176 
P. Bennett
262  J. Hedley
65
n/r 
Crosland
79, 52
351  B. Hoole
76, 62
n/r 
G. Willis
285  K. Hobbs
127 
C. Shutt
89, 70, 74, 50
451  M. Hirst
50
223 
J. Moore
68
281  E. Warren
235 
Whiteley
220  P. Welham
205 
D. Causier
73, 51
470  G. Evans
291 
Quarter-Finals
Broken Reed

Reed's run ended at the hands - or cue - of 17-year-old Paul Bennett. Causier had two more breaks in the nineties. Jamie Moore had a good chance of beating Shutt but failed at the last gasp. Graham Willis's good run came to an end against Crosland who was looking on good form.

P. Bennett
77
335  W. Reed
156 
Crosland
76, 56, 51
429  G. Willis
143 
C. Shutt
274  J. Moore
259 
D. Causier
98, 96, 55, 52
577  S. Whiteley
117 
Semi-Finals
Crosland gives a Lesson

The Crosland - Bennett game was well balanced until the Yorkshire schoolmaster made day's highest break of 139. Causier at last converted one of his ninety breaks into a century and out-gunned Shutt

Crosland
139
332  P. Bennett
225 
D. Causier
104, 67, 54, 52
531  C. Shutt
77
302 
Final
Hard Lines for Sir

Neither Causier nor Crosland played as well as they had done earlier. Players tire as the day goes on. Causier played some very good strokes but was unable to put together any significant breaks. Crosland struggled with his game and could not get much above the thirty mark. He might have considered himself a shade unlucky with the running towards the end of the game as Causier pulled away to finish a comfortable winner.

D. Causier
401  S. Crosland
265 

Derngate Plate

First Round
Three close games

Chris Ross had a good win over Nottingham player Gerry Tutt, but the other games were all touch and go, the closest being that in which Tom Hodby beat Brian Dix by only 5.

C. Ross
127  G. Tutt
45 
M. White
101  R. Shanks
86 
F. Page
114  J. McGregor
93 
T. Hodby
143  B. Dix
140 
Second Round
Mike breaks his Duck

Hooray for Mike Billinge. The genial west-countryman is well-known as an excellent referee, indeed he is a professional referee. He is less well-known as a player, and though he has played in national one-day tournaments for a good few years he had, until today, never won a match. This must be a record for the most consecutive losses and is a bit strange because, whilst Mike is not championship material, he is not that bad a player. Harry Willis will not mind being Mike's first victim - but he is going to get his leg pulled a bit. So well done Mike, we all know that you are much too stable a person to let this success go to your head, but, remember the words of Joe Davis about winning, "Make it a habit."

C. Ross
168  M. White
51 
M. Billinge
114  H. Willis
67 
R. Watts
200  R. Moore
76 
W. Andress
178  C. Hudson
67 
J. Barker
155  A. Parson
90 
J. Conba
102  T. Smith
94 
J. Carman
143  A. Marsden
102 
T. Hodby
168  F. Page
69 
Quarter-Finals
Billinge Fails. West Country Tie

The BQR Editor thought it would be a good idea to referee the Billinge game to see if the secret of success might be revealed. But Mike was giving nothing away as he went down to Chris Ross. The Watts/Andress clash finished appropriately in a tie with Dick out-pointing Bill 69 - 30 in the extra ten minutes. Tom Hodby had another close one this time losing to John Carman by 5. John Barker did well to beat Jerry Conba.

C. Ross
54
168  M. Billinge
51 
R. Watts
233  W. Andress
194 
J. Barker
166  J. Conba
75 
J. Carman
138  T. Hodby
133 
Semi-Finals
Ross all the way

The Ross-Watts game was expected to be close but Ross came through comfortably. John Barker's good run came to an end against John Carman.

C. Ross
192  R. Watts
82 
J. Carman
114  J. Barker
71 
Final
(one hour)
Ross all the way

John Carman had played well all day but seemed unable to get into the game as Chris Ross, though having only one half-century, scored consistently out-pointing his opponent by two to one.

C. Ross
54
383  J. Carman
184 
Not one of the best of ABC days spoiled a little perhaps by the humid atmosphere in the club - not the club's fault of course - and by an unexpectedly low turnout. Playing conditions varied from pretty good to the not quite so good. Even so, there is no doubt that those present enjoyed their billiards as usual, and for this thanks to Derek Townend. David Causier has made a good start to the season with this win following his runner-up position to Gilchrist at Leeds. Enthusiasts are waiting the first Causier - Goodwill clash, perhaps this will come at Widnes.